By Chris Allaire
It still surprises hiring teams when a great candidate declines an offer, especially in a market that’s no longer the free-for-all it was in 2022. But even though the economy cooled and tech experienced massive layoffs, candidates are still saying “no,” and they’re doing it for predictable reasons.
Let’s ground this conversation in what’s actually happening out there.
The 2025 Tech Hiring Reality Check
The last few years flipped the market on its head:
- Over 166,000 tech workers were laid off in Q1 2023 alone — more than in all of 2022.
- Hiring slowed 12% across tech in 2023–2024, the first sustained decline since the Great Recession.
- Offer rates dropped dramatically: only about 7% of technical candidates interviewed received an offer in 2023, and although that improved slightly in 2024, it’s still well below 2021–2022 levels.
- Compensation expectations shifted: 57% of candidates have rejected offers citing low or unclear pay.
- Flexibility matters: 42% of candidates won’t even apply if the work model (remote, hybrid, office) doesn’t match their preference.
- Candidate experience now determines the outcome: nearly half of U.S. job seekers turned down an offer because of a poor interview experience.
So yes, the market changed. But the psychology behind accepting or rejecting a job has not.
Here’s why people still turn down offers in 2025, backed by data.
1. The Role Doesn’t Feel Like a True Step Forward
After years of layoffs and reshuffling, candidates are more cautious than ever. They’re not leaving for a slight bump, they’re leaving for meaningful progress.
Studies show candidates prioritize:
- Skills growth and career advancement
- Clearer role definition and ownership
- Tech stacks that match where the industry is moving (AI, ML, MLOps, Platform Engineering)
If the move feels lateral, risky, or unclear, they stay put.
In this market, stability is compensation.
2. Compensation Doesn’t Match Risk or Market Reality
The #1 reason candidates rejected offers in the last two years? Low or unfair pay.
A few more numbers:
- 57% of rejected offers cited compensation.
- Nearly half of job seekers now expect salary ranges disclosed upfront.
- Inflation + uncertainty = candidates valuing guaranteed cash over speculative equity.
People aren’t chasing the biggest number — they’re chasing fairness, transparency, and stability.
If your comp philosophy is vague or your offer is off-market by 10–20%, candidates will pass without hesitation.
3. Flexibility Still Wins — Even in a Slower Market
Despite a shift toward hybrid and office-first policies:
- 42% of candidates won’t pursue roles that don’t match their flexibility preferences.
- “Return to office” is one of the top reasons candidates reject offers, second only to compensation.
- Commute length is now a top 5 dealbreaker again for the first time since 2019.
People have redesigned their lives around flexibility. They’re not giving that up unless the role is exceptional.
4. The Interview Experience Turns Them Off
This is the most avoidable reason offers fall apart and the most common.
Multiple studies show:
- 49% of candidates have declined an offer due to a poor interview experience (messy process, ghosting, disorganization).
- 26% rejected offers due to slow communication or unclear expectations.
- “How I was treated during the interview process” is now a top factor in accepting a role.
Candidates don’t judge your culture by your Careers page, they judge it by:
- how prepared interviewers are
- how consistent the messaging is
- how quickly they get updates
- how respected they feel
The experience is the product.
5. Culture, Leadership & Stability Don’t Match the Pitch
Candidates have become investigators. Before accepting an offer, they’re digging into:
- Glassdoor and Blind
- LinkedIn tenure trends
- Layoff history and funding stability
- Public comments from leadership
- How the company handled the last 24 months
And here’s a big one:
- More than 70% of candidates say culture fit is a key deciding factor in accepting or rejecting an offer.
If what you say and what they see don’t match, trust breaks and the offer dies.
6. The Market Feels Risky — and You Didn’t De-Risk the Move
Even with fewer competing offers:
- 1 in 3 candidates still back out after accepting an offer, according to Gartner.
- Market volatility (AI consolidation, funding shifts, reorganizations) spooks candidates if employers don’t proactively address it.
Silence is not safety.
Candidates need to hear why hiring is happening now and why the role is stable.
So… How Do You Get More Yeses in 2025?
1. Diagnose “Why Now?” on Day One
Understand motivation early and track it every step of the way.
2. Treat Candidate Experience Like a Core Product
Intentional, consistent, human communication can increase acceptance rates dramatically.
3. Be Transparent About Comp, Flexibility & Stability
No surprises. No vague answers. Clear beats clever every time.
4. Use Data to Guide, Not Guess
Market alignment is now a competitive advantage.
5. Partner with Recruiters Who Actually Talk to People
AI screens resumes.
Averity screens humans.
We catch concerns early, keep candidates engaged, and help teams land the people they truly want, not the first person who says yes.
The Takeaway
Candidates aren’t rejecting offers because they’re picky.
They’re rejecting offers because:
- The job doesn’t feel like a true upgrade
- The risk isn’t matched with reward
- Flexibility is ignored
- The process signals disorganization
- Culture and leadership feel off
- The market feels scary and no one explained why this role is safe
When employers understand these patterns and address them with honesty, clarity, and empathy, hiring becomes faster, easier, and far more successful.
And that’s what people-first recruiting looks like in 2025.
Create an Account or Sign In